Wine ratings

What wine scores mean

By the Goblet team · Updated

Wine scores come in three kinds. Critic scores, usually out of 100, are one expert’s judgement of quality: 90 and above means outstanding. Crowd ratings, usually out of 5 stars, average many drinkers’ opinions. A personal score predicts how much you in particular will enjoy the wine. They answer different questions, which is why they often disagree.

Critic scores: the 100-point scale

The 100-point scale was popularised in the 1980s by the critic Robert Parker and is used by publications such as Wine Spectator and Wine Enthusiast. In practice only the top part of the scale is used:

ScoreWhat it generally means
95–100Classic, extraordinary
90–94Outstanding
85–89Very good
80–84Good, sound
Below 80Rarely published

Exact bands vary by publication. A score is a judgement of quality and typicity by an experienced taster. It is not a prediction of whether you will like the wine: a 96-point, very tannic young Barolo is a superb wine that many people will not enjoy tonight.

Crowd ratings: stars out of 5

Scanner apps show the average star rating of everyone who rated a wine. Averages are useful for spotting duds and crowd-pleasers, but they bunch together in a narrow band, and they reward wines that please the most people. If your taste is anywhere off the middle, the crowd’s favourite is not yours.

Why scores disagree

  • Different questions. Critics judge quality; crowds report enjoyment; both are averaged over people who are not you.
  • Different palates. Some critics prefer ripe, powerful wines; others fresh and restrained.
  • Bottle and context. Vintage, storage and food change how the same wine shows.

A score for your palate

Goblet’s score answers the only question that matters at the moment of choosing: how much will I like this? It is out of 10, on the same scale you rate wines with, and it comes from your own ratings rather than critics or crowds. A famous bottle that does not suit you scores low, and it should. Each pick comes with a plain-English reason, in terms of wines you have already rated.

Know which wine you’ll love, in one photo

Goblet scans a bottle, a wine list or a whole shelf and scores every wine for your own palate. Free on iPhone and Android.

Download on theApp StoreGet it onGoogle Play

Frequently asked questions

What does a 90-point wine mean?

On the 100-point scale used by critics, 90 to 94 means outstanding. It is one expert’s judgement of the wine’s quality, not a guarantee that you will enjoy it.

Who invented the 100-point wine rating scale?

The critic Robert Parker popularised the 100-point scale in the 1980s through his newsletter The Wine Advocate. Publications such as Wine Spectator and Wine Enthusiast use similar scales.

Is a 4-star wine on a wine app good?

A high crowd rating means many people enjoyed the wine. Because crowd averages bunch in a narrow range and favour crowd-pleasing styles, it does not tell you whether you personally will like it.

Why do wine critics and apps give different scores?

They answer different questions. Critics judge quality and typicity; app ratings average the enjoyment of many drinkers. Neither is built around your own palate.

Is there a wine rating based on my own taste?

Yes. Goblet scores wines out of 10 for your palate, learned from a short quiz and the wines you rate, and explains each score in plain English.

Keep reading